Photo-Illustration: New York Magazine; Source picture: Sciocomm Media
This article was featured in One Great Story, New York’s studying suggestion e-newsletter. Sign up here to get it nightly.
For the previous three years, one of the most important podcasters on the planet has instructed a story to tens of millions of listeners throughout half a dozen exhibits: There was a little boy, and the boy’s household was comfortable, till in the future, the boy’s household fell aside. The boy was despatched away. He foundered, he discovered remedy, he discovered science, he discovered train. And he turned sturdy.
Today, Andrew Huberman is a stiff, jacked 48-year-old affiliate professor of neurology and ophthalmology on the Stanford University School of Medicine. He is given to delivering three-hour lectures on topics equivalent to “the health of our dopaminergic neurons.” His podcast is revelatory largely as a result of it doesn’t condescend, which has not been the best way of public-health info in our time. He doesn’t give the impression of somebody diluting science to universally relevant sound bites for the slobbering lots. “Dopamine is vomited out into the synapse or it’s released volumetrically, but then it has to bind someplace and trigger those G-protein-coupled receptors, and caffeine increases the number, the density of those G-protein-coupled receptors,” is how he explains the impact of espresso earlier than train in a two-hour-and-16-minute deep dive that has, as of this writing, practically 8.9 million views on YouTube.
Falling for Dr. Huberman
Millions of people really feel compelled to listen to him draw distinctions between neuromodulators and classical neurotransmitters. Many of these people will then undertake an related “protocol.” They will comply with his elaborate morning routine. They will mannequin essentially the most fundamental features of human life — sleeping, consuming, seeing — on his sober advice. They will inform their mates to do the identical. “He’s not like other bro podcasters,” they are going to say, and they are going to be appropriate; he’s a tenured Stanford professor related to a Stanford lab; he is aware of the distinction between a neuromodulator and a neurotransmitter. He is simply back from a sold-out tour in Australia, the place he stuffed the Sydney Opera House. Stanford, at one level, hung indicators (AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY) apparently to discourage followers in search of the lab.
With this energy comes the facility to raise different scientists out of their slender silos and switch them, too, into celebrities, however these scientists is not going to be Huberman, whose private appeal is distinct. Here now we have a broad-minded professor puppyishly enamored with the wonders of organic perform, beneficiant to interviewees (“I love to be wrong”), engaged in endearing makes an attempt to sound like a regular individual (“Now, we all have to eat, and it’s nice to eat foods that we enjoy. I certainly do that. I love food, in fact”).
This is a world wherein the tender artwork of self-care is made concrete, wherein Goop-adjacent platitudes discover solidity in peer review. “People go, ‘Oh, that feels kind of like weenie stuff,’” Huberman tells Joe Rogan. “The data show that gratitude, and avoiding toxic people and focusing on good-quality social interactions … huge increases in serotonin.” “Hmmm,” Rogan says. There is a kindness to the best way Huberman reminds his viewers all the time of the probabilities of neuroplasticity: They can change. He has modified. As an adolescent, he says, he endured the tough divorce of his mother and father, a Stanford professor who labored within the tech industry and a youngsters’s-book creator. The period after the separation was, he says, one of “pure neglect.” His father was gone, his mom “totally checked out.” He was pressured, round age 14, to endure a month of “youth detention,” a state of affairs that was “not a jail,” however harrowing in its own proper.
“The thing that really saved me,” Huberman tells Peter Attia, “was this therapy thing … I was like, Oh, shit … I do have to choke back a little bit here. It’s a crazy thing to have somebody say, ‘Listen,’ like, to give you the confidence, like, ‘We’re gonna figure this out. We’re gonna figure this out.’ There’s something very powerful about that. It wasn’t like, you know, ‘Everything will be okay.’ It was like, We’re gonna figure this out.”
The wayward son would dedicate himself to remedy and in addition to science. He would flip Rancid all the best way up and research all night time long. He can be tenured at Stanford together with his own lab, severing optic nerves in mice and noting what grew back.
Huberman has been in remedy, he says, since high college. He has, in actual fact, a number of therapists, and psychiatrist Paul Conti seems on his podcast ceaselessly to debate psychological well being. Therapy is “hard work … like going to the gym and doing an effective workout.” The mind is a machine that wants tending. Our cells will benefit from the cautious management of stress. “I love mechanism,” says Huberman; our emotions are integral to the equipment. There are Huberman Husbands (males who optimize), a phenomenon to not be confused with #DaddyHuberman (utilized by ladies on TikTook within the man’s thrall).
A prophet should constrain his self-revelation. He should give his story a form that finally tends towards interior power, weak point overcome. For Andrew Huberman to turn out to be your instructor and mine, as he very a lot was for a period this fall — a period wherein I diligently absorbed solar upon waking, drank no more than as soon as a week, practiced physiological sighs in site visitors, and mentioned to myself, out loud in my lounge, “I also love mechanism”; a period during which I started to suppose significantly, for the primary time in my life, about decreasing stress, and during which each my husband and my younger baby noticed tangible benefit from repeatedly immersing themselves in frigid water; a period wherein I spotted that I not solely favored this podcast however favored different ladies who favored this podcast — he have to be, ultimately, higher than the remainder of us.
Huberman sells a dream of control down to the mobile stage. But one thing has gone improper. In the midst of immense fame, a chasm has opened between the podcaster preaching dopaminergic restraint and a man, with newfound wealth, with entry to a world unseen by most professors. The drawback with a man all the time engaged on himself is that he might also be engaged on you.
Some of Andrew’s earliest Instagram posts are of his lab. We see smiling undergraduates “slicing, staining, and prepping brains” and a wall of framed science publications wherein Huberman-authored papers seem: Nature, Cell Reports, The Journal of Neuroscience. In 2019, underneath the deal with @hubermanlab, Andrew started posting simple academic videos wherein he talks immediately into the digital camera about topics such because the organizational logic of the mind stem. Sometimes he would speak over a easy anatomical sketch on lined paper; the impression was, as it’s now, of a fast-talking instructor in dialog with an clever scholar. The videos amassed a fan base, and Andrew was, in 2020, invited on some of the most important podcasts on this planet. On Lex Fridman Podcast, he talked about experiments his lab was conducting by inducing worry in people. On The Rich Roll Podcast, the connection between respiratory and motivation. On The Joe Rogan Experience, experiments his lab was conducting on mice.
He was a fluid, partaking conversationalist, wealthy with insight and knowledgeable advice. In a 12 months of loss of life and illness, when many felt a sense of company slipping away, Huberman had a light plan. The subtext was all the time the identical: We might dwell in chaos, however there are mechanisms of control.
By then he had a companion, Sarah, which isn’t her actual title. Sarah was somebody who may speak to anybody about something. She was dewy and robust and in her mid-40s, although she seemed a decade youthful, with two small youngsters from a earlier relationship. She had previous mates who adored her and no bother making new ones. She got here throughout as scattered in the best way she jumped readily from matter to matter in dialog, dropping the thread earlier than returning to it, however she was in actual fact extraordinarily organized. She was a girl who saved monitor of issues. She was an entrepreneur who may set up a assembly, a talent she would need later for causes she couldn’t probably have predicted. When I requested her a query in her home just lately, she mentioned the reply can be on an previous telephone; she stood up, left for less than a second, and returned with a field labeled OLD PHONES.
Sarah’s relationship with Andrew started in February 2018 within the Bay Area, the place they each lived. He messaged her on Instagram and mentioned he owned a home in Piedmont, a rich metropolis separate from Oakland. That turned out to not be exactly true; he lived off Piedmont Avenue, which was in Oakland. He was courtly and a bit formal, as he would later be on the podcast. In July, in her backyard, Sarah says she requested to make clear the depth of their relationship. They determined, she says, to be unique.
Both had devoted their lives to wholesome residing: train, good meals, good info. They cared immoderately about what went into their our bodies. Andrew may command a room and clearly took pleasure in doing so. He was busy and good-looking, wholesome and intensely formidable. He appeared of engaged on himself; all through their relationship, he would speak about “repair” and “healthy merging.” He was dedicated to his bullmastiff, Costello, whom he fearful over continually: Was Costello comfy? Sleeping correctly? Andrew favored to dote on the canine, she says, and he favored to be doted on by Sarah. “I was never sitting around him,” she says. She cooked for him and felt glad when he relished what she had made. Sarah was keen to have unprotected intercourse as a result of she believed they have been monogamous.
On Thanksgiving in 2018, Sarah deliberate to introduce Andrew to her mother and father and close mates. She was cooking. Andrew texted repeatedly to say he can be late, then later. According to a pal, “he was just, ‘Oh yeah, I’ll be there. Oh, I’m going to be running hours late.’ And then of course, all of these things were planned around his arrival and he just kept going, ‘Oh, I’m going to be late.’ And then it’s the end of the night and he’s like, ‘Oh, I’m so sorry this and this happened.’”
Huberman disappearing was one thing of a sample. Friends, girlfriends, and colleagues describe him as arduous to achieve. The record of causes for not displaying up included a e-book, time-stamping the podcast, Costello, wildfires, and a “meetings tunnel.” “He is flaky and doesn’t respond to things,” says his pal Brian MacKenzie, a well being influencer who has collaborated with him on respiratory protocols. “And if you can’t handle that, Andrew definitely is not somebody you want to be close to.” “He in some ways disappeared,” says David Spiegel, a Stanford psychiatrist who calls Andrew “prodigiously smart” and “intensely engaging.” “I mean, I recently got a really nice email from him. Which I was touched by. I really was.”
In 2018, earlier than he was well-known, Huberman invited a Colorado-based investigative journalist and anthropologist, Scott Carney, to his home in Oakland for a few days; the 2 would go tenting and talk about their mutual curiosity in actionable science. It had been Huberman, a fan of Carney’s e-book What Doesn’t Kill Us, who initially reached out, and the 2 turned pleasant over telephone and e-mail. Huberman confirmed Carney’s record of tenting gear: sleeping bag, bug spray, boots.
When Carney bought there, the 2 didn’t go tenting. Huberman merely disappeared for many of a day and a half whereas Carney stayed home with Costello. He puttered round Huberman’s place, shopping for a juice, strolling via the neighborhood, ready for him to return. “It was extremely weird,” says Carney. Huberman texted from elsewhere saying he was busy engaged on a grant. (A spokesperson for Huberman says he clearly communicated to Carney that he went to work.) Eventually, as an alternative of tenting, the 2 went on a few short hikes.
Even when bodily current, Huberman will be arduous to trace. “I don’t have total fidelity to who Andrew is,” says his pal Patrick Dossett. “There’s always a little unknown there.” He describes Andrew as an “amazing thought partner” with “almost total recall,” such a memory that one feels the need to watch what one says; a stray remark may floor three years later. And but, at different instances, “you’re like, All right, I’m saying words and he’s nodding or he is responding, but I can tell something I said sent him down a path that he’s continuing to have internal dialogue about, and I need to wait for him to come back.”
Andrew Huberman declined to be interviewed for this story. Through a spokesman, Huberman says he didn’t turn out to be unique with Sarah till late 2021, that he was not doted on, that duties between him and Sarah have been shared “based on mutual agreement and proficiency,” that their Thanksgiving plans have been tentative, and that he “maintains a very busy schedule and shows up to the vast majority of his commitments.”
In the autumn of 2020, Huberman bought his home in Oakland and rented one in Topanga, a wooded canyon enclave contiguous with Los Angeles. When he got here back to Stanford, he stayed with Sarah, and when he was in Topanga, Sarah was typically with him.
When they fought, it was, she says, sometimes as a result of Andrew would fixate on her previous decisions: the lads she had been with earlier than him, the 2 youngsters she had had with one other man. “I experienced his rage,” Sarah remembers, “as two to three days of yelling in a row. When he was in this state, he would go on until 11 or 12 at night and sometimes start again at two or three in the morning.”
The relationship struck Sarah’s mates as odd. At one level, Sarah mentioned, “I just want to be with my kids and cook for my man.” “I was like, Who says that?” says a close pal. “I mean, I’ve known her for 30 years. She’s a powerful, decisive, strong woman. We grew up in this very feminist community. That’s not a thing either of us would ever say.”
Another pal discovered him irritating to be round. “I try to be open-minded,” she mentioned of the connection. “I don’t want to be the most negative, nonsupportive friend just because of my personal observations and disgust over somebody.” When they have been collectively, he was buzzing, anxious. “He’s like, ‘Oh, my dog needs his blanket this way.’ And I’m like, ‘Your dog is just laying there and super-cozy. Why are you being weird about the blanket?’”
Sarah was not the one one that skilled the extent of Andrew’s anger. In 2019, Carney despatched Huberman supplies from his then-forthcoming e-book, The Wedge, wherein Huberman seems. He requested Huberman to substantiate the elements wherein he was talked about. For months, Huberman didn’t reply. Carney despatched a follow-up e-mail; if Huberman didn’t reply, he would assume the whole lot was correct. In 2020, after months of saying he was too busy to review the supplies, Huberman known as him and, Carney says, got here at him in a rage. “I’ve never had a source I thought was friendly go bananas,” says Carney. Screaming, Huberman threatened to sue and accused Carney of “violating Navy OpSec.”
It had turn out to be, by then, one of essentially the most perplexing relationships of Carney’s life. That 12 months, Carney agreed to Huberman’s invitation to swim with sharks on an island off Mexico. First, Carney must spend a month of his summer season getting licensed in Denver. He did, at appreciable expense. Huberman then canceled the journey a day earlier than they have been set to go away. “I think Andrew likes building up people’s expectations,” says Carney, “and then he actually enjoys the opportunity to pull the rug out from under you.”
In January 2021, Huberman launched his own podcast. Its popularity can be immediately tied to his position as instructor and scientist. “I’d like to emphasize that this podcast,” he would say each episode, together with his explicit mixture of formality and discursiveness, “is separate from my teaching and research roles at Stanford. It is, however, part of my desire and effort to bring zero-cost-to-consumer information about science and science-related tools to the general public.”
“I remember feeling quite lonely and making some efforts to repair that,” Huberman would say on an episode in 2024. “Loneliness,” his interviewee mentioned, “is a need state.” In 2021, the nation was within the later levels of a need state: bored, alone, powerless. Huberman provided not solely hours of educative listening however a plan to construction your day. A plan for waking. For consuming. For exercising. For sleep. At a time when life had shifted to screens, he introduced people back to their corporeal selves. He suggested a “physiological sigh” — two short breaths in and a long one out — to scale back stress. He pulled numerous people from their laptops and put them in rhythm with the solar. “Thank you for all you do to better humanity,” learn feedback on YouTube. “You may have just saved my life man.” “If Andrew were science teacher for everyone in the world,” somebody wrote, “no one would have missed even a single class.”
Asked by Time final 12 months for his definition of enjoyable, Huberman mentioned, “I learn and I like to exercise.” Among his most well-known episodes is one wherein he declares reasonable consuming decidedly unhealthy. As MacKenzie places it, “I don’t think anybody or anything, including Prohibition, has ever made more people think about alcohol than Andrew Huberman.” While he claims repeatedly that he doesn’t wish to “demonize alcohol,” he fails to masks his apparent disapproval of anybody who consumes alcohol in any amount. He follows a time-restricted consuming schedule. He discusses constraint even in pleasure, as a result of a dopamine spike is invariably adopted by a drop beneath baseline; he explains how even a small pleasure like a cup of espresso earlier than each exercise reduces the capability to release dopamine. Huberman ceaselessly refers back to the significance of “social contact” and “peace, contentment, and delight,” all the time talked about as a triad; these are finally leveraged for the one worth constantly espoused: physiological well being.
In August 2021, Sarah says she learn Andrew’s journal and found a reference to dishonest. She was, she says, “gutted.” “I hear you are saying you are angry and hurt,” he texted her the identical day. “I will hear you as much as long as needed for us.”
Andrew and Sarah needed youngsters collectively. Optimizers typically desire to not conceive naturally; one can exert more control when procreation entails a lab. Sarah started the primary of a number of rounds of IVF. (A spokesperson for Huberman denies that he and Sarah had determined to have youngsters collectively, clarifying that they “decided to create embryos by IVF.”)
In 2021, she examined constructive for a high-risk kind of HPV, one of the variants linked to cervical most cancers. “I had never tested positive,” she says, “and had been tested regularly for ten years.” (A spokesperson for Huberman says he has by no means examined constructive for HPV. According to the CDC, there may be presently no accredited take a look at for HPV in males.) When she introduced it up, she says, he instructed her you might contract HPV from many issues.
“I’d be remiss if I didn’t ask about truth-telling and deception,” Andrew instructed evolutionary psychologist David Buss on a November 2021 episode of Huberman Lab known as “How Humans Select & Keep Romantic Partners in Short & Long Term.” They have been speaking about regularities throughout cultures in mate preferences.
“Could you tell us,” Andrew requested, “about how men and women leverage deception versus truth-telling and communicating some of the things around mate choice selection?”
“Effective tactics for men,” mentioned a gravel-voiced, 68-year-old Buss, “are often displaying cues to long-term interest … men tend to exaggerate the depths of their feelings for a woman.”
“Let’s talk about infidelity in committed relationships,” Andrew mentioned, laughing. “I’m guessing it does happen.”
“Men who have affairs tend to have affairs with a larger number of affair partners,” mentioned Buss. “And so which then by definition can’t be long-lasting. You can’t,” added Buss wryly, “have the long-term affairs with six different partners.”
“Yeah,” mentioned Andrew, “unless he’s, um,” and right here Andrew seemed into the gap. “Juggling multiple, uh, phone accounts or something of that sort.”
“Right, right, right, and some men try to do that, but I think it could be very taxing,” mentioned Buss.
By 2022, Andrew was legitimately well-known. Typical headlines learn “I tried a Stanford professor’s top productivity routine” and “Google CEO Uses ‘Nonsleep Deep Rest’ to Relax.” Reese Witherspoon instructed the world that she was sure to get ten minutes of daylight within the morning and tagged Andrew. When he was not on his own podcast, Andrew was on another person’s. He saved the place in Topanga, however he and Sarah started splitting rent in Berkeley. In June 2022, they absolutely mixed lives; Sarah relocated her household to Malibu to be with him.
According to Sarah, Andrew’s rage intensified with cohabitation. He fixated on her determination to have youngsters with one other man. She says he instructed her that being along with her was like “bobbing for apples in feces.” “The pattern of your
11 years, while rooted in subconscious drives,” he instructed her in December 2021, “creates a nearly impossible set of hurdles for us … You have to change.”
Sarah was, in actual fact, altering. She felt herself getting smaller, continually appeasing. She apologized, again and again and again. “I have been selfish, childish, and confused,” she mentioned. “As a result, I need your protection.” A spokesperson for Huberman denies Sarah’s accounts of their fights, denies that his rage intensified with cohabitation, denies that he fixated on Sarah’s determination to have youngsters with one other man, and denies that he mentioned being along with her was like bobbing for apples in feces. A spokesperson mentioned, “Dr. Huberman is very much in control of his emotions.”
The first three rounds of IVF didn’t produce wholesome embryos. In the spring of 2022, enraged again about her previous, Andrew requested Sarah to elucidate intimately what he known as her unhealthy decisions, most particularly having her second baby. She wrote it out and browse it aloud to him. A spokesperson for Huberman denies this incident and says he doesn’t regard her having a second baby as a unhealthy alternative.
I feel it’s important to acknowledge that we would have a mannequin of who somebody is,” says Dossett, “or a model of how someone should conduct themselves. And if they do something that is out of sync with that model, it’s like, well, that might not necessarily be on that person. Maybe it’s on us. Our model was just off.”
Huberman’s specialty lies in a slender subject: visual-system wiring. How comfy one feels with the science propagated on Huberman Lab relies upon totally on how a lot leeway one is keen to provide a man who expounds for a number of hours a week on topics properly exterior his space of experience. His detractors observe that Huberman extrapolates wildly from restricted animal research, posits certainty the place there may be ambiguity, and stumbles when he veers too removed from his slender realm of research, however even they are going to are inclined to admit that the podcast is an expansive, free (or, as he places it, “zero-cost”) compendium of human data. There are quack company, however these are significantly outnumbered by profound, advanced, affected person, and sometimes shifting descriptions of organic course of.
Huberman Lab is premised on the picture of a working scientist. One imagines clear white counters, rodents in cages, postdocs peering into microscopes. “As scientists,” Huberman says ceaselessly. He speaks typically, too, of the significance of mentorship. He “loves” studying instructor evaluations. On the web, one can go to the lab and even donate. I’ve by no means met a Huberman listener who doubted the existence of such a place, and this seems to be by design. In a glowing 2023 profile in Stanford journal, we be taught “Everything he does is inspired by this love,” however don’t be taught that Huberman lives 350 miles and a six-hour drive from Stanford University, making it tough to drop into the lab. Compounding the difficulty is the truth that the lab, in line with educated sources, barely exists.
“Is a postdoc working on her own funding, alone, a ‘lab?’” asks a researcher at Stanford. There had been a lab — 4 rooms on the second flooring of the Sherman Fairchild Science Building. Some of them smelled of mice. It was right here that researchers anesthetized rodents, injected them with fluorescence, broken their optic nerves, and watched for the newly vivid nerves to grow back.
The lab, says the researcher, was already scaling down earlier than COVID. It was emptying out, postdocs apparently unsupervised, a quarter-million-dollar laser-scanning microscope gathering mud. Once the researcher noticed somebody are available in and reclaim a $3,500 rocker, a machine for mixing options.
Shortly earlier than publication, a spokesperson for Stanford mentioned, “Dr. Huberman’s lab at Stanford is operational and is in the process of moving from the Department of Neurobiology to the Department of Ophthalmology,” and a spokesperson for Huberman says the tools in Dr. Huberman’s lab remained in use till the final postdoc moved to a college place.
On each episode of his “zero-cost” podcast, Huberman provides a prolonged endorsement of a powder previously often called Athletic Greens and now as AG1. It is one factor to listen to Athletic Greens promoted by Joe Rogan; it’s maybe one other to listen to somebody who sells himself as a Stanford University scientist simply back from the lab proclaim that this $79-a-month powder “covers all of your foundational nutritional needs.” In an industry not famous for its integrity, AG1 is, in line with author {and professional} debunker Derek Beres, “one of the most egregious players in the space.” Here now we have a powder that accommodates, in line with its own advertising, 75 lively elements, far more than the standard complement, which would appear a promoting level however for the inconveniences of mass. As efficiency nutritionist Adam McDonald factors out, the huge quantity of elements signifies that every ingredient, which can or might not promote good well being in a sure dose, is probably going included in minuscule quantities, although customers are left to do the mathematics themselves; the corporate retains many of the numbers proprietary. “We can be almost guaranteed that literally every supplement or ingredient within this proprietary blend is underdosed,” explains McDonald; the numbers, he says, don’t seem so as to add up to something analysis has proven to be significant in phrases of human well being outcomes. And certainly, “the problem with most of the probiotics is they’re typically not concentrated enough to actually colonize,” one learns from Dr. Layne Norton in a November 2022 episode of Huberman Lab. (AG1 argues that probiotics are efficient and that the 75 elements are “included not only for their individual benefit, but for the synergy between them — how ingredients interact in complex ways, and how combinations can lead to additive effects.”) “That’s the good news about podcasts,” Huberman mentioned when Wendy Zukerman of Science Vs identified that her podcast would by no means make suggestions primarily based on such tenuous analysis. “People can choose which podcast they want to listen to.”
Whenever Sarah had suspicions about Andrew’s interactions with one other girl, he had a explicit method of speaking in regards to the girl in query. She says he mentioned the ladies have been stalkers, alcoholics, and compulsive liars. He instructed her that one girl tore out her hair with chunks of flesh connected to it. He instructed her a story about a girl who fabricated a story about a useless child to “entrap” him. (A spokesperson for Huberman denies the account of the denigration of ladies and the dead-baby story and says the hair story was taken out of context.) Most of the time, Sarah believed him; the ladies most likely have been loopy. He was a superstar. He needed to be cautious.
It was in August 2022 that Sarah observed she and Andrew couldn’t exit with out being thronged by people. On a tenting journey in Washington State that very same month, Sarah introduced syringes and a cooler with ice packs. Every day of the journey, he injected the medicine meant to stimulate fertility into her abdomen. This was spherical 4.
Later that month, Sarah says she grabbed Andrew’s telephone when he had left it within the rest room, checked his texts, and located conversations with somebody we’ll call Eve. Some of them came about during the tenting journey that they had simply taken.
“Your feelings matter,” he instructed Eve on a day when he had injected his girlfriend with hCG. “I’m actually very much a caretaker.” And later: “I’m back on grid tomorrow and would love to see you this weekend.”
Caught having an affair, Andrew was apologetic. “The landscape has been incredibly hard,” he mentioned. “I let the stress get to me … I defaulted to self safety … I’ve also sat with the hardest of feelings.” “I hear your insights,” he mentioned, “and honestly I appreciate them.”
Sarah observed how courteous he was with Eve. “So many offers,” she identified, “to process and work through things.”
Eve is an ethereally stunning actress, the type of girl from whom it’s arduous to look away. Where Sarah exudes a winsome chaotic vitality, Eve is intimidatingly collected. Eve noticed Andrew on Raya in 2020 and messaged him on Instagram. They went for a swim in Venice, and he complimented her kind. “You’re definitely,” he mentioned, “on the faster side of the distribution.” She discovered him to be an extraordinary listener, and she or he favored the best way he seemed to be desirous about her inner life. He was busy all of the time: together with his e-book, and finally the podcast; his canine; obligations at Stanford. “I’m willing to do the repair work on this,” he mentioned when she known as him out for standing her up, or, “This sucks, but doesn’t deter my desire and commitment to see you, and establish clear lines of communication and trust.” Despite his infinite excuses for not displaying up, he appeared, to Eve, to be critical about deepening their relationship, which lasted on and off for 2 years. Eve had the impression that he was not seeing anybody else: She was keen to have unprotected intercourse.
As their relationship intensified over time, he talked typically in regards to the household he in the future needed. “Our children would be amazing,” he mentioned. She requested for e-book suggestions and he instructed, jokingly, Huberman: Why We Made Babies. “I’m at the stage of life where I truly want to build a family,” he instructed her. “That’s a resounding theme for me.” “How to mesh lives,” he mentioned in a voice memo. “A fundamental question.” One time she heard him say, on Joe Rogan, that he had a girlfriend. She texted him to ask about it, and he responded instantly. He had a stalker, he mentioned, and so his crew had determined to invent a companion for the listening public. (“I later learned,” Eve tells me with attribute equanimity, “that this was not true.”)
In September 2022, Eve observed that Sarah was taking a look at her Instagram tales; not commenting or liking, simply wanting. Impulsively, Eve messaged her. “Is there anything you’d rather ask me directly?” she mentioned. They set up a call. “Fuck you Andrew,” she messaged him.
Sarah moved out in August 2023 however says she remained in a dedicated relationship with Huberman. (A spokesperson for Huberman says they have been separated.) At Thanksgiving that 12 months, she observed he was “wiggly” each time a cellular phone got here out on the desk — attempting to keep away from, she suspected, being photographed. She says she didn’t go away him till December. According to Sarah, the connection ended, because it had began, with a lie. He had been at her place for a couple of days and left for his place
to organize for a Zoom call; they deliberate to go Christmas buying the subsequent day. Sarah confirmed up at his home and located him on the sofa with one other girl. She may see them via the window. “If you’re going to be a cheater,” she advises me later, “do not live in a glass house.”
On January 11, a girl we’ll call Alex started liking all of Sarah’s Instagram posts, seven of them in a minute. Sarah messaged her: “I think you’re friends with my ex, Andrew Huberman. Are you one of the woman he cheated on me with?” Alex is an intense, direct, extremely educated girl who lives in New York; she was sleeping with Andrew; and she or he had no thought there had been a girlfriend. “Fuck,” she mentioned. “I think we should talk.” Over the next weeks, Sarah and Alex by no means stopped texting. “She helped me hold my boundary against him,” says Sarah, “keep him blocked. She said, ‘You need to let go of the idea of him.’” Instead of texting Andrew, Sarah texted Alex. Sometimes they only talked about their days and never about Andrew in any respect. Sarah nonetheless thought stunning Eve, alternatively, “might be crazy,” however they talked some more and introduced her into the group chat. Soon there have been others. There was Mary: a dreamy, charismatic Texan he had been seeing for years. Her mates known as Andrew “bread crumbs,” given his tendency to vanish. There was a fifth girl in L.A., funny and fast-talking. Alex had been apprehensive; she felt silly for believing Andrew’s lies and fearful that the opposite ladies would appear silly, subsequently compounding her disgrace. Foolish ladies weren’t, nonetheless, what she discovered. Each of the 5 was assertive and profitable and educated and sharp-witted; there had been a sort, and so they have been numerous expressions of that sort. “I can’t believe how crazy I thought you were,” Mary instructed Sarah. No one struck anybody else as a stalker. No one had made up a story about a useless child or torn out hair with chunks in it. “I haven’t slept with anyone but him for six years,” Sarah instructed the group. “If it makes you feel any better,” Alex joked, “according to the CDC,” that they had all slept with each other.
The ladies in contrast time-stamped screenshots of texts and assembled therein an extraordinary file of deception.
There was a day in Texas when, after Sarah left his resort, Andrew slept with Mary and texted Eve. They discovered days wherein he would textual content practically equivalent footage of himself to 2 of them on the similar time. They realized that the day earlier than he had moved in with Sarah in Berkeley, he had slept with Mary, and he had additionally been along with her in December 2023, the weekend earlier than Sarah caught him on the sofa with a sixth girl.
They realized that on March 21, 2021, a day of admittedly spectacular logistical jujitsu, whereas Sarah was in Berkeley, Andrew had flown Mary from Texas to L.A. to stick with him in Topanga. While Mary was there, visiting from 1000’s of miles away, he left her with Costello. He drove to a espresso store, the place he met Eve. They had a critical speak about their relationship. They thought they have been in a good place. He needed to make it work.
“Phone died,” he texted Mary, who was ready back on the place in Topanga. And later, to Eve: “Thank you … For being so next, next, level gorgeous and sexy.”
“Sleep well beautiful,” he texted Sarah.
“The scheduling alone!” Alex tells me. “I can barely schedule three Zooms in
a day.”
In the combination, Andrew’s therapeutic language took on a sinister edge. It was speaking a dedication that was not actual, a profound curiosity within the internality of ladies that was then used to govern them.
“Does Huberman have vices?” asks an nameless Reddit poster.
“I remember him saying,” reads the primary remark, “that he loves croissants.”
While Huberman has been criticized for having too few ladies company on his podcast, he’s solicitous and deferential towards these he interviews. In a January 2023 episode, Dr. Sara Gottfried argues that “patriarchal messaging” and white supremacy contribute to the deterioration of ladies’s well being, and Andrew responds with a story about how his beloved trans mentor, Ben Barres, had skilled “intense suppression/oppression” at MIT earlier than transitioning. “Psychology is influencing biology,” he says with concern. “And you’re saying these power dynamics … are impacting it.”
In non-public, he may typically appear much less involved about patriarchy. Multiple ladies recall him saying he most popular the type of relationship wherein the girl was monogamous however the man was not. “He told me,” says Mary, “that what he wanted was a woman who was submissive, who he could slap in the ass in public, and who would be crawling on the floor for him when he got home.” (A spokesperson for Huberman denies this.) The ladies continued to check notes. He had his little methods of checking in: “Good morning beautiful.” There was a explicit method he would reply to a attractive image: “Mmmmm hi there.”
A spokesperson for Huberman insisted that he had not been monogamous with Sarah till late 2021, however a recorded dialog he had with Alex instructed that in May of that 12 months he had led Sarah to imagine in any other case. “Well, she was under the impression that we were exclusive at that time,” he mentioned. “Women are not dumb like that, dude,” Alex responded. “She was under that impression? Then you were giving her that impression.” Andrew agreed: “That’s what I meant. I’m sorry, I didn’t mean to put it on her.”
The type of ladies to whom Andrew Huberman was attracted; the type of ladies who have been interested in him — these have been ladies who paid consideration to what went into their our bodies, ladies who made avoiding toxicity a central focus of their lives. They researched non-hormone-disrupting merchandise, averted sugar, ate natural. They have been disgusted by the data that that they had had intercourse with somebody who had an untold quantity of companions. All of them questioned how many others there have been. When Sarah discovered Andrew with the opposite girl, there had been a black pickup truck within the driveway, and she or he had taken a image. The ladies traced the plates, however they hit a useless finish and by no means discovered her.
Tell us in regards to the darkish triad,” he had mentioned to Buss in November on the journey wherein he slept with Mary.
“The dark triad consists of three personality characteristics,” mentioned Buss. “So narcissism, Machiavellianism, and psychopathy.” Such people “feign cooperation but then cheat on subsequent moves. They view other people as pawns to be manipulated for their own instrumental gains.” Those “who are high on dark-triad traits,” he mentioned, “tend to be good at the art of seduction.” The overwhelming majority of them have been males.
Andrew instructed one of the ladies that he wasn’t a intercourse addict; he was a love addict. Addiction, Huberman says, “is a progressing narrowing of things that bring you joy.” In August 2021, the identical month Sarah first realized of Andrew’s dishonest, he launched an episode with Anna Lembke, chief of the Stanford Addiction Medicine Dual Diagnosis Clinic. Lembke, the creator of a e-book known as Dopamine Nation, gave a clear rationalization of the dopaminergic roots of dependancy.
“What happens right after I do something that is really pleasurable,” she says, “and releases a lot of dopamine is, again, my brain is going to immediately compensate by downregulating my own dopamine receptors … And that’s that comedown, or the hangover or that aftereffect, that moment of wanting to do it more.” Someone who waits for the sensation to go, she defined, will reregulate, go back to baseline. “If I keep indulging again and again and again,” she mentioned, “ultimately I have so much on the pain side that I’ve essentially reset my brain to what we call anhedonic or lacking-in-joy type of state, which is a dopamine deficit state.” This is a state wherein nothing is fulfilling: “Everything sort of pales in comparison to this one drug that I want to keep doing.”
“Just for the record,” Andrew mentioned, smiling, “Dr. Lembke has … diagnosed me outside the clinic, in a playful way, of being work addicted. You’re probably right!”
Lembke laughed. “You just happen to be addicted,” she mentioned gently, “to something that is really socially rewarded.”
What he failed to know, he mentioned, was people who ruined their lives with their illness. “I like to think I have the compassion,” he mentioned, “but I don’t have that empathy for taking a really good situation and what from the outside looks to be throwing it in the trash.”
At least three ex-girlfriends stay pleasant with Huberman. He “goes deep very quickly,” says Keegan Amit, who dated Andrew from 2010 to 2017 and continues to admire him. “He has incredible emotional capacity.” A high-school girlfriend says each she and he have been “troubled” during their time collectively, that he was sophisticated and jealous however “a good person” whom she parted with on good phrases. “He really wants to get involved emotionally but then can’t quite follow through,” says somebody he dated on and off between 2006 and 2010. “But yeah. I don’t think it’s …” She hesitates. “I think he has such a good heart.”
Andrew grew up in Palo Alto simply earlier than the daybreak of the web, a misplaced metropolis. He provides some model of his origin story on The Rich Roll Podcast; he repeats it for Tim Ferriss and Peter Attia. He tells Time journal and Stanford journal. “Take the list of all the things a parent shouldn’t do in a divorce,” he just lately instructed Christian bowhunter Cameron Hanes. “They did them all.” “You had,” says Wendy Zukerman in her vivid Aussie accent, “a wayward childhood.” “I think it’s very easy for people listening to folks with a bio like yours,” says Tim Ferriss, “to sort of assume a certain trajectory, right? To assume that it has always come easy.” His father and mom agree that “after our divorce was an incredibly hard time for Andrew,” although they “do not agree” with some of his characterization of his previous; few mother and father wish to be accused of “pure neglect.”
Huberman wouldn’t present the title of the detention middle wherein he says he was held for a month in high college. In a model of the story Huberman tells on Peter Attia’s podcast, he says, “We lost a couple of kids, a couple of kids killed themselves while we were there.” (New York was unable to search out an account of this occasion.)
Andrew attended Gunn, a high-performing, high-pressure high college. Classmates describe him as all the time with a skateboard; they bear in mind him as nice, “sweet,” and never significantly tutorial. He would, says one former classmate, “drop in on the half-pipe,” the place he was “encouraging” to different skaters. “I mean, he was a cool, individual kid,” says one other classmate. “There was one year he, like, bleached his hair and everyone was like, ‘Oh, that guy’s cool.’” It was a rich place, the type of setting the place the phrase au pair comes up ceaselessly, and Andrew didn’t stand out to his classmates as out of control or unpredictable. They don’t recall him entering into avenue fights, as Andrew claims he did. He was, says Andrew’s father, “a little bit troubled, yes, but it was not something super-serious.”
What does appear sure is that in his adolescence, Andrew turned a common shopper of speak remedy. In remedy, one learns to inform tales about one’s expertise. A narrative one may inform is: I overcame immense odds to be the place I’m. Another is: The son of a Stanford professor, born at Stanford Hospital, grows up to be a Stanford professor.
I’ve by no means,” says Amit, “met a man more interested in personal growth.” Andrew’s relationship to remedy stays intriguing. “We were at dinner once,” says Eve, “and he told me something personal, and I suggested he talk to his therapist. He laughed it off like that wasn’t ever going to happen, so I asked him if he lied to his therapist. He told me he did all the time.” (A spokesperson for Huberman denies this.)
“People high on psychopathy are good at deception,” says Buss. “I don’t know if they’re good at self-deception.” With repeated listening to the podcast, one discerns a man present process, in public, an effort to know himself. There are hours of speaking about dependancy, trauma, dopamine, and worry. Narcissism comes up constantly. One can see makes an attempt to know and in addition locations the place these makes an attempt swerve into self-indulgence. On a current episode with the Stanford-trained psychiatrist Paul Conti, Andrew and Conti have been describing the psychological phenomenon of “aggressive drive.” Andrew had an instance to share: He as soon as canceled an appointment with a Stanford colleague. There was no response. Eventually, he obtained a reply that mentioned, in Andrew’s telling, “Well, it’s clear that you don’t want to pursue this collaboration.”
Andrew was, he mentioned to Conti, “shocked.”
“I remember feeling like that was pretty aggressive,” Andrew instructed Conti. “It stands out to me as a pretty salient example of aggression.”
“So to me,” mentioned Huberman, “that seems like an example of somebody who has a, well, strong aggressive drive … and when disappointed, you know, lashes back or is passive.”
“There’s some way in which the person doesn’t feel good enough no matter what this person has achieved. So then there is a sense of the need and the right to overcontrol.”
“Sure,” mentioned Huberman.
“And now we’re going to work together, right, so I’m exerting significant control over you, right? And it may be that he’s not aware of it.”
“In this case,” mentioned Andrew, “it was a she.”
This girl, defined Conti, primarily based totally on Andrew’s description of two emails, had allowed her unhealthy “excess aggression” to be “eclipsing the generative drive.” She required that Andrew “bowed down before” her “in the service of the ego” as a result of she didn’t be ok with herself.
This dialog extends for an extraordinary 9 minutes, each males egging one another on, analysis after analysis, salient, maybe, for causes different than these the 2 establish. We be taught that this individual lacks gratitude, generative drive, and happiness; she suffers from envy, low “pleasure drive,” and basic unhappiness. It would seem, at a distance, to be an elaborate fantasy of an insane girl constructed on a single habits: At some level in time, a girl determined she didn’t wish to work with a man who didn’t show up.
There is an argument to be made that it doesn’t matter how a useful podcaster conducts himself exterior of the studio. A person unable to constrain his urges should preach dopaminergic control to others. Morning solar stays salutary. The physiological sigh, employed by this author many instances within the writing of this essay, continues to impact calm. The giant and rising distance between Andrew Huberman and the person he continues to be might not even matter to those that purchase questionable merchandise he has really useful and from which he’ll materially benefit, or listeners who imagined a man in a white coat at work in Palo Alto. The people who definitively discover the space between fantasy and actuality to be a drawback are ladies who fell for a podcaster who professed deep, sustained concern for his or her private growth, and who, in his skyrocketing affect, continued to mission an picture of earnest self-discovery. It is right here, within the false perception of two minds in synchronicity and exploration, that deception results in hurt. They worry it should result in more.
“There’s so much pain,” says Sarah, her voice breaking. “Feeling we had made mistakes. We hadn’t been enough. We hadn’t been communicating. By making these other women into the other, I hadn’t really given space for their hurt. And let it sink in with me that it was so similar to my own hurt.”
Three of the ladies on the group textual content met up in New York in February, and the group has solely grown nearer. On any given day, one of the 5 can go into an appointment and are available back to 100 texts. Someone shared a Reddit thread wherein a commenter claimed Huberman had a “stable full a hoes,” and one other responded, “I hope he thinks of us more like Care Bears,” at which level they assigned themselves Care Bear names. “Him: You’re the only girl I let come to my apartment,” learn a meme somebody shared; underneath it was a yellow lab wanting extraordinarily skeptical. They commonly use Andrew’s standard response to express photographs (“Mmmmm”) to touch upon footage of each other’s pets. They are holding space for different ladies who may be part of.
“This group has radicalized me,” Sarah tells me. “There has been so much processing.” They are planning a weekend collectively this summer season.
“It could have been sad or bitter,” says Eve. “We didn’t jump in as besties, but real friendships have been built. It has been, in a strange and unlikely way, quite a beautiful experience.”
Additional reporting by Amelia Schonbek and Laura Thompson.
Thank you for subscribing and supporting our journalism.
If you like to learn in print, you can too discover this text within the March 25, 2024, difficulty of
New York Magazine.
Want more tales like this one? Subscribe now
to help our journalism and get limitless entry to our protection.
If you like to learn in print, you can too discover this text within the March 25, 2024, difficulty of
New York Magazine.